The Best Colts of All-Time

The following players went to at least one Pro Bowl as a member of the Colts franchise. For a list of other teams, click here.

Player	Pos	Status	Legends Score	Avg/Year
Peyton Manning	QB		125	6.94
Johnny Unitas	QB		85	4.72
Gino Marchetti	DE		67	4.47
Ted Hendricks	OLB		64	4.27
Jim Parker	T		60	5.45
Marvin Harrison	WR		53	4.08
Lenny Moore	RB		44	3.67
Art Donovan	DT		43	3.58
Eric Dickerson	RB		41	3.73
Marshall Faulk	RB		40	3.33
Dwight Freeney	DE		40	2.5
Raymond Berry	WR		39	3
Adam Vinatieri	K	Eligible 2025	33	1.38
Bobby Boyd	CB	Eligible 1974	32	3.56
John Mackey	TE		32	3.2
Edgerrin James	RB		30	2.73
Alan Ameche	RB	Eligible 1966	30	5
Quenton Nelson	LG	Active	24	4
George Kunz	RT	Eligible 1986	22	1.83
Earl Morrall	QB	Eligible 1982	21	1
Darius Shaquille Leonard	LB	Active	21	3.5
Rohn Stark	P	Eligible 2003	21	1.31
Jeff Saturday	C	Eligible 2018	19	1.36
Chris Hinton	G	Eligible 2001	18	1.38
Bert Jones	QB	Eligible 1988	18	1.8
Reggie Wayne	WR	Eligible 2020	17	1.21
Mike McCormack	T		15	1.25
Dick Barwegen	LG	Eligible 1960	14	1.75
Jimmy Orr	WR	Eligible 1976	13	1
Mike Curtis	ILB	Eligible 1984	12	0.86
Bob Sanders	S	Eligible 2017	12	1.5
John Dutton	DE	Eligible 1993	11	0.79
DeForest Buckner	DT	Active	11	1.38
Bob Vogel	LT	Eligible 1978	11	1.1
Robert Mathis	OLB	Eligible 2022	10	0.71
Bubba Smith	DE	Eligible 1982	10	1
Lydell Mitchell	RB	Eligible 1986	9	1
Andy Nelson	LS	Eligible 1970	9	1.13
Luke Rhodes	LS	Active	9	1.13
Mike Vanderjagt	K	Eligible 2014	9	0.82
Ray Donaldson	C	Eligible 2002	9	0.53
Chris Gardocki	P	Eligible 2012	9	0.56
Art Spinney	LG	Eligible 1966	8	0.73
Rick Volk	FS	Eligible 1984	8	0.67
Ordell Braase	DE	Eligible 1974	8	0.67
Pat McAfee	P	Eligible 2022	7	0.88
Ryan Kelly	C	Active	7	0.88
Willie Richardson	WR	Eligible 1977	7	0.78
Dean Biasucci	K	Eligible 2001	7	0.58
Jonathan Taylor	RB	Active	6	1.5
Dallas Clark	TE	Eligible 2019	6	0.55
Dick Szymanski	C	Eligible 1974	6	0.43
Dan Edwards	WR	Eligible 1960	6	1.2
Cary Blanchard	K	Eligible 2006	6	0.67
Tom Keane	RS	Eligible 1961	6	0.75
Bert Rechichar	RS	Eligible 1967	6	0.6
George Taliaferro	QB	Eligible 1961	6	1
Bill Curry	C	Eligible 1980	5	0.5
Ron Solt	G	Eligible 1998	4	0.44
Duane Bickett	OLB	Eligible 2002	4	0.33
Cato June	LB	Eligible 2015	4	0.57
T.Y. Hilton	WR	Active	4	0.33
Roger Carr	WR	Eligible 1989	4	0.4
Fred Miller	DT	Eligible 1978	3	0.3
Jerry Logan	S	Eligible 1978	3	0.3
Andrew Luck	QB	Eligible 2024	3	0.43
Will Wolford	LT	Eligible 2004	3	0.23
Antoine Bethea	FS	Eligible 2025	3	0.21
Tarik Glenn	LT	Eligible 2012	3	0.3
Clarence Verdin	WR	Eligible 2000	2	0.22
Toni Linhart	K	Eligible 1985	2	0.25
Vontae Davis	CB	Eligible 2024	2	0.2
Jack Doyle	TE	Eligible 2027	2	0.22
Mike Adams	S	Eligible 2025	2	0.13
Brad Ecklund	C	Eligible 1959	2	0.4
Tom Matte	RB	Eligible 1978	2	0.17
Joe Washington	RB	Eligible 1991	1	0.11
Kenny Moore	CB	Active	1	0.14
Lenny Lyles	CB	Eligible 1966	1	0.33
Zollie Toth	RB	Eligible 1960	1	0.2
Ken Dilger	TE	Eligible 2010	1	0.1
Joseph Addai	RB	Eligible 2017	1	0.17
Bruce Laird	KR	Eligible 1991	1	0.07
D'Qwell Jackson	ILB	Eligible 2022	1	0.09
Jim Harbaugh	QB	Eligible 2007	1	0.07
Gardner Minshew	QB	Active	1	0.2
Spec Sanders	S	Eligible 1956	1	0.2
Buddy Young	RB	Eligible 1961	1	0.17
Norm Bulaich	RB	Eligible 1985	1	0.1
Jim Mutscheller	WR	Eligible 1967	1	0.13
Matt Overton	LS	Active	1	0.08
Mike Barnes	DT	Eligible 1987	1	0.11
Eric Ebron	TE	Active	1	0.1
Don Joyce	DE	Eligible 1968	1	0.08

Share